1959 Topps Bob Gibson #514

do you like that smile?

I can't decide if this is god tier or A+. It's such a tough card that it really probably deserves god tier, but I have to put it at A+ with the slight centering shift. Insane card though either way.

Damn.. Looks perfect to me.

Gorgeous. The ever so slightest tilt and left to right centering shift prevents a GT.

This may very well become the first unanimous God Tier card we have on the site. I could nit pick the left right centering, but no. The card is stunning. The color. The focus of his face. Corners, borders, edges. It has it all. This body slams so many 8s I have seen in my decades of collecting.

Perfection!

Colors POP and sharp images and clean and bright borders. Cannot get better than this

More like MINT 9. Another case of collectors needing to step in and right the wrongs of "the system." Happy to do my part. Watch this card outrank 8s and 9s in badge and EyeQ.

This is a card I know well, and it simply doesn’t get much better. For me, this is god-tier. The presentation is flawless—nothing distracts from the imagery, and the overall look is exceptional. As far as Bob Gibson rookies go, you’d be hard-pressed to find one with stronger visual appeal. An absolute standout.